KF228-20196J5Y – Clergy Malpractice – Sex Slavery, Trafficking, Keith Raniere Guilty on All Counts – Religious Daycare for Children?

contributed via email by T.J.

confidential, HIPPA privacy protected, & mission-specific collaborations are here
open comments for general public and open subscribers are below
Admin PLB Accountant, Dick Roma

Quick Link – Includes Jury Verdict Sheet

This new case regarding Keith Raniere does not qualify on the same order of magnitude for clergy malpractice as the landmark case, F.G v. MacDonell and its lineage.

Popular reporting of the Raniere case labels the followers of Keith Raniere as a ‘cult’. This label is melodrama because the label might lead naive readers to assume the Raniere case has no relevance for clergy and full-time caregiving in cases of spiritual care. The Raniere case does not distinguish between cult and religion. The case does not give criteria to know the difference between cult and religion. Anyone who wants extra reading, see one of the best explorations of the confused lines between cult and religion, where cult and religion sometimes merge, by Marci Hamilton, a leading scholar of constitutional law who specializes in church/state issues, see “JUSTICE DENIED: What America Must Do to Protect Its Children” (Cambridge 2008, 2012), who wrote also, “GOD VS. THE GAVEL: Religion and the Rule of Law” (Cambridge 2005, 2007).

In short, the Raniere case puts us back into the territory already identified as the confused boundaries where cult and religion mergeThis case does apply to clergy and to full-time spiritual caregivers. 

The plot of the Raniere case is ancient.  The plot goes back at least to the story of the unnamed woman concubine in Judges 19–20, a woman from Bethlehem who lived with a Levite priest in the hill country of Ephraim.  The woman is raped to death. The priest does nothing to save her.  The rape causes the first bloody civil war between the tribes of God’s people.

Here are a few issues from the case of Keith Raniere that are issues all the way back in history to Judges 19-20.  They are relevant in our work as full-time mentors and students.

For one issue, the case raises old issues about how and when spiritual authority becomes abused by people with authority so that men or women insiders are coerced, threatened, ‘blackmailed’, or by violence put under pressures to have sex with leaders – by forced ‘consent’?  More generally, what is consent? 

For another issue, the case raises age-old questions about whether consent can include consent to be a ‘slave’? This issue of consensual slavery is not trivial. Arguments that people want to be slaves are more common than we think.  Especially in arguments in favor of sex-slavery, the argument goes that sex and human trafficking victims really want the protections of their slavery.  Arguments today are cloaked under fancy rhetoric about voluntary consent.  Arguments in court and in social policy arguments try and justify many forms of slavery in the U.S.  These arguments go back at least to the shameful era of the Fugitive Slave ActAnd before that – some justified by theology from pulpits.

For another issue, with questions about sex, sex slavery, and sex trafficking put aside, the Raniere case raises questions about how and when people with authority create obedience ‘slaves’ to spiritual authority for a variety of ‘religious’ purposes and chores. Sometimes without the perpetrators and victims knowing.  Almost always without admitting – almost always denying – that they are creating slaves.  Just joking? just read the Raniere case.

A most troubling issue in the practice by followers of Raniere is that they ran eleven daycare centers for children worldwide.  The existence of children in day care may have played a huge role – a far greater role than can be published in popular media because we do not have access to the subjective opinions of the jury – the jury decision includes unpublished juror reasons for judging to convict Raniere on all counts.  Good judges expect impartial juries.  The problem with juries of our peers is that jurors are our peers and they are mothers and fathers too. 

… distributed by email to users as 20196J5Y.docx, and 20196J5Y.odt

Published by

T.J. (Jurist)

Training Focus ~ semi-retired judge ~ free to hand pick court cases and devote rest of my time to spiritual mentoring ~ mentoring agency professionals, law enforcement, others in government in spiritual discernment ~  mentoring some full-time students from churches that send people to court to pray silently ~ mentoring former guilty parties coming to Redemption ~ training is in full time prayer into judgments ~ judgments to bless Good everywhere ~ judgments to cause catastrophe to evil in “pay every penny” restorative judgments (Luke 12:59, Matthew 5:26) ~ judge for Tender Mercies never strained in chances to start Life again.  Participating in new legal trend of out of court settlements using private arbitration and private settlement agreements for churches and clergy sued or threatened with lawsuits for malpractice (especially botched exorcisms), for failing to refer troubled subjects to counseling as a compliment to valid pastoral care, and for false, immature, and shallow self-promotional claims of faith healing that have made medical conditions worse and sometimes led to death.  My special desire is lovingly to educate fallen clergy, help them in correct techniques of cooperation, and restore mistaken and sued clergy back to pastoral ministry with new Hope, Mercy, and the Wisdom that is Calling in the Streets.  We are all under Grace.

7 thoughts on “KF228-20196J5Y – Clergy Malpractice – Sex Slavery, Trafficking, Keith Raniere Guilty on All Counts – Religious Daycare for Children?”

  1. Tejvan Pettinger analyzed differences between “Religions and Cults,” and made a bibliography of them. I agree that the popular press wants sensationalism in branding Raniere as a cult. Did the biblical concubine consent to her sexual slavery? For her publicity, just because she was nailing a priest? Big game. Her sexual slavery to the priest turned into high level slavery to death as she tried to crawl by her painted fingernails to the front door where she died.

  2. T.J., I cannot find the location of your question to me about sharing mission experiences.

    Perhaps this can be done through exploring the psychiatry of demonic possession in Gallagher?

    Much of what happened in missions fits into Gallagher’s book.

    This combination of Gallagher and mission work almost fits with your subject matter here

    We do not know facts and statistics about clergy sexual abuse of children and child slavery to religious authorities. I agree this subject gets sensationalized. It trivializes, commercializes the underlying abuse. Deep State. And dark.

    Testing the interest in exploring Dr. Richard Gallagher’s book.

    If interest exists, and some already does, then perhaps we may work through his book on hidden, non-public back-pages.

    Mutual sharing of our cases on this subject matter is not appropriate in public pages.

  3. Michael (M.D.), I want Gallagher. Some private pages, some public. Not all private. My vote.

  4. Lynette Franco was told by her pastors and elders to forgive and forget an incident in 1986 in which she said she was the victim of child rape by a church member.

    The ‘authority’ of religious office was used in this direction of forgiveness without exploring the possibility of the truth of her story.

    Cardinal McCarrick was finally charged with criminal sexual abuse only a few days ago on July 29 for an incident that went back to 1974.

    Churches have counted on the statute of limitations to protect guilty clergy and their church boards and this defense of the statute of limitations has failed so far in this case.

    The case is not over just because criminal charges are now filed.

    I see an open question whether repeated efforts to cover up any crime by clergy amount to valid reasons as ongoing crimes for extending the statute of limitations?

    And this open question includes the added open question whether a cover up exists because authority is used to push forgiveness instead of pushing for finding out the facts and truth?

  5. Hey very nice website!! Man .. Beautiful .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your I’m happy to find a lot of useful info here in the post, we need work out more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing. . . . . .

  6. I have to show some appreciation to you for bailing me out of this incident. Right after searching through the the web and finding tricks which were not beneficial, I believed my life was over. Being alive without the presence of answers to the difficulties you’ve solved by means of your main write-up is a critical case, as well as the kind that might have in a negative way affected my career if I hadn’t noticed your site. Your own competence and kindness in handling the whole thing was tremendous. I’m not sure what I would have done if I hadn’t discovered such a stuff like this. I can also at this time look ahead to my future. Thanks for your time very much for this specialized and result oriented help. I won’t be reluctant to propose your web page to any individual who would need counselling about this area.

  7. Heya i am for the first time here. I came across this board and I find It really useful & it helped me out a lot. I hope to give something back and aid others like you helped me.

Leave a Reply to Michael (M.D.) Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.